Surprisingly, the Michigan bill to ban
smoking in public places is getting closer to becoming a law, as State
Senate voted 25 to 12 to ban smoking in all bars, restaurants and workplaces.
The bill returns to the House, which has been waiting since
December for the Senate to act. The House could send the bill as early as next
week to Gov. Jennifer Granholm.
Granholm backs the smoking prohibition in part because it might
have a positive influence on youngsters, as studies have shown that teenagers
are less likely to take up smoking in communities which interdict it.
Senate Majority Leader Mike Bishop called it a “blatant
overreach” of government into private affairs.
“When will it stop? How much control do you want? And when
will people have to stop thinking for themselves entirely?” asked Bishop,
according to the Chicago Tribune.
Another Senator, Raymond Basham, is a big supporter of this
bill and says that the measure is necessary especially for those who work in
smoky public places and cannot avoid the smoke by leaving, as their job requires
them to be there. Some republicans are also in favor of the bill because
studies have shown the effects of second hand smoking.
The bill that passed the House five months ago made an
exception from the ban for casinos, bingo halls, horse tracks, cigar bars and
smoke shops. But now, the Senate got rid of those provisions in favor of
banning smoking in all workplaces.
The Michigan Licensed Beverage Association criticized
Thursday’s vote, saying that bars and restaurants should be allowed to set
their own policies based on what customers want.
Since the State of Ohio
closed the door on smoking, Michigan
businesses like Nick and Jimmy's in Temperance have been reaping the benefits,
as they have more customers.
“I’d say about 50 percent of our customers come up from Ohio just to smoke here in Michigan, which helps out our business,” says
Lindsay Miller, who works at Nick and Jimmy's, reports a local source.
On the other hand, supporters of the legislation say that
the ban won’t affect bars or restaurants economically.
“It shows that he has heard our concerns about the greater
good for all Michigan
residents,” said Judy Stewart, spokeswoman for the Campaign for Smokefree
Air.