Real beauty lies within. Haven’t we heard this already? Perhaps
we have, but sometimes it can be very refreshing to hear it again, especially
in a modern fairytale film which casts Christina Ricci and Reese Witherspoon as
two young girls ready tot face the world.
Each moral must have its own fable and in the case of
“Penelope,” it is a story about beauty and ugliness, about the obsessions of
modern society, about worshipping celebrity and many, many other topics.
This unfortunately is one of the movie’s shortcomings: it tries
to explore too many levels and you know that the final twist will be a
happy-end within the first five minutes of the film.
“Penelope” is about… Penelope, a poor little rich girl from
an aristocratic family, who is born with a pig’s snout because of an ancient
curse, due to the sins of her ancestors. Of course, there is a way to lift the
curse: by finding a own-of-her-kind, blue-blooded suitor.
In a questionable decision, Jessica and Franklin Wilhern
(Catherine O'Hara and Richard E. Grant) keep her hidden in a mansion, until
Penelope reaches adulthood, when her mother decides to call in an entire bunch
of young, beautiful, rich aristocrats.
And this seems to be just another flaw of the story. After
trying so hard to hide her daughter, Mrs. Wilhern suddenly decides to call a
bunch of unknown people into her house. Hello, matrimonial agencies have been
invented! So have dating sites.
However, each and every of the would-be suitors leaves the
house, not out the door but through the nearest window, screaming and crying,
after catching just a glimpse of Penelope’s not so ugly (but rather cute) pig
snout.
This is perhaps the main flaw of the movie. What should have
acted as the story’s justification fails to impress. Ok, I’m ready to believe
that plastic surgery, despite its latest advancements, is not the answer to
Penelope’s problem, but then again she is not really as ugly as we are supposed
to consider her.
Since the story is not among the most original, why didn’t
the film’s creators at least try to learn something from “Ugly Betty,” who does
much better in the credibility department?
Back to the story, one of the window jumpers breaks the
story to the media and Lemon (Peter Dinklage), a tabloid vulture who has a personal
vendetta against the Wilherns, decides to hire an I’ll-do-anything-for-money aristocrat,
Max (James McAvoy) to pose as suitor and obtain photos of Penelope’s embarrassing
pig snout.
The plan seems perfect, but Max discovers that, behind her
ugliness, Penelope is a smart, funny person, perfectly loveable – and he does
fall in love with her.
Ashamed of his real intentions, Max decided to flee from Penelope’s
life, leaving her feeling hurt and betrayed.
So she decides to see how the real, bad world is and in her
exploring journey meets Annie (Reese Witherspoon), a punkish Vespa-riding
firecracker of a girl who shows her the ways of the world in a town that seems
to be a mix between a 19-th century London and a
modern day New York.
As you can imagine, it takes about few minutes before the
media exposes the well-guarded secret of Penelope, and with her face on the
cover of every major tabloid, she has to teach the world and herself the lesson
that beauty is just a detail.
With any other cast, “Penelope,” directed by debutant Mark
Palansky from a script by Leslie Caveny, a TV sitcom veteran, would have failed.
With all the twists and spins, the story still unfolds in a predictable manner.
But the cast saves the movie. Christina Ricci, the girl who
made her way in the movie industry as one of the members of another awkward
family, the Addams, plays a perfect Penelope, a girl in whom her mother induced
the idea that her physical defect will outcast her forever from a normal life.
Penelope’s journey in the world and the way she discovers
who she really is are perfectly portrayed by Ricci, who instills charm and
credibility in her character.
Similarly inspired is casting Catherine O’Hara as the
mother. In any other circumstances, “Penelope” could have been a story about
the relationship between mothers and daughters, about the generation gap, but
the relaxation with which O’Hara portrays Jessica Wilhern only helps save the
movie.
Reese Witherspoon, who also took on producing duties with
this project, proves, even with a supporting role, how a brilliant actor can
transform the most banal story into one oozing charm and vivacity.
Annie is the film’s necessary character, the opposite to the
girl born and raised far from the real world. Cynical and endearing, Witherspoon
makes good pairing with the restrained Ricci.
Perhaps their short encounter inspires you to make another
movie with the two actresses as costars? It would be a real gain.
Overall, “Penelope” is likable; it has a story and most
importantly, a moral. It will entertain you, on one condition: do not expect
from it more than it is – a fairytale with brilliant actors.