 |
|
|
A civil liberties group sued the New York Police Department Thursday
trying to stop its officers from detaining and questioning photographers and
filmmakers who take pictures of city landmarks.
The suit was filed on behalf of Arun Wiita, 26, a Columbia University
graduate student, who was handcuffed in July after an officer spotted him
taking pictures of a Manhattan
subway station. He was released after a half hour, saying that he was
humiliated by the encounter although never being charged with a crime.
Lawyers for the New York Civil Liberties Union, representing
the student said the police had made an abuse violating his First Amendment
rights and accused them of systematically harassing photographers taking
pictures in public places, which is a legal activity.
"There has been a constant refrain that we've heard from the
photography community for several years now," said Christopher Dunn, NYCLU
associate legal director and the lead attorney on the case, according to
Reuters.
The NYCLU stated that this was not the first case of a photographer being harassed
by the police this way. Indian documentary filmmaker Rakesh Sharma complained
earlier this year for being harassed in the same way by the police when filming
in Manhattan in
2005.
"People cannot be arrested or handcuffed for taking pictures,"
said Dunn.
Wiita believed the officers had questioned him because of his ethnicity. He was
born in the U.S., his family
lives in New Jersey, but his mother is from India. He also
said that he is seeking compensatory damages, although he does not expect a big
payout.
"I would much rather see the NYPD change its procedures," he said
Police spokesperson, Paul Browne said that officers are
questioning people photographing the city’s rail infrastructure in order to
prevent terrorism.
"On rare occasions the NYPD makes inquiries of individuals
photographing subways and infrastructure. Why? Because of the multiple plots to
attack the subways since 9/11 involving photography of subways and other
targets," he said, according to the Associated Press.
© 2007 - 2009 - eFluxMedia